Ratings and reviews
5 Burro Cafe Photos
Hours
| Monday | 12:00 PM - 1:00 AM (Next day) |
| Tuesday | 12:00 PM - 1:00 AM (Next day) |
| Wednesday | 12:00 PM - 1:00 AM (Next day) |
| Thursday | 12:00 PM - 1:00 AM (Next day) |
| Friday | 12:00 PM - 1:00 AM (Next day) |
| Saturday | 12:00 PM - 1:00 AM (Next day) |
| Sunday | 12:00 PM - 1:00 AM (Next day) |
5 Burro Cafe Reviews
What a great little hole in the wall. This is a gem. Love this place and will be coming back. Place has great food and a great vibe. Music playing. Decor that makes you feel like a tropical vibe. Great drinks. They have flavorful margaritas of all flavors. I love the modelo negra. Very small and quaint. Cozy for 2. Must try the food. Had shrimp cocktails and flautas. It's more Mexican dishes. To end the night the bartender brought us a round of shots.
Went there on a Sunday night and the place was packed. The frozen coconut margaritas were dangerously delicious. I don't usually like margaritas but was told I had to try one - so glad I did!! We started off with the cheese and bean nachos. They were delicious, simple but very flavorful. I ordered the fish tacos (mahi mahi) omg, they were amazing!!! Maybe the best fish tacos, similar to the ones I had in Maui which set a very high bar. Everyone enjoyed their meals. The service was very friendly and attentive. Cannot wait to go back.
You really can't go wrong eating here. The food is made with a little bit of magic. I usually get the steak burritos and have never been disappointed on flavor. The only disappointment is when your plate is empty and there is no more to enjoy. Space is in the smaller end; you'll be happier in parties of 2-4. It's a vibrant space with lots to look at on the walls. Service is friendly and fast. Drinks are delicious and pack a punch!
We visited after too long of an absence and thanked our lucky stars as we got seated right away at this popular and bustling cafe! Even the hostess told us this was our lucky night as there is always a wait to get in. Yippee! While the place is on the small side and gets a bit cramped, it is such a a unique and welcoming place that allows you to feel instantly comfortable and relaxed. While 5 Burro's is well known for their frozen margaritas (they are fantastic) we opted for some Corona's (no draft beers, only bottles) and tequila shots. Complementary chips and salsa were bright to the table. We ordered the Mexican salad con carne with skirt steak-- a favorite go to that I have never gotten better anywhere. Their in house made dressing makes it so good. All was fresh and delicious. We loved picking some tunes to play on the jukebox. Service was super friendly and attentive. The restrooms were clean and well maintained. On street parking only. Can't wait to come back.
Very nostalgic place . Been coming here for over 25 years . Had many dates here with my now husband . Fortunate enough to bring out teenage children here . The steak salad always hits home . Tender steak perfectly cooked and the most freshest avocado salad with the most fantastic lemony dressing Best frozen margaritas in town !!! Never fails !!! Thank you for the continued great memories
Get food Great service very good service from host to server and busser And the food is really good cooked steak was amazing. Pitcher of margaritas hot the spot for Sure .
5 Burro Cafe
Nestled in the heart of Forest Hills, 5 Burro Cafe offers a delightful escape for locals and visitors alike. Whether you're in the mood for a delicious Mexican meal or a relaxed dining experience, this charming restaurant is the place to be. Located at 72-05 Austin St, Forest Hills, NY 11375, 5 Burro Cafe combines a vibrant atmosphere with an impressive menu, making it a must-visit in this cozy neighborhood.
Discovering the Vibe of 5 Burro Cafe
If you're craving authentic Mexican food in a welcoming environment, 5 Burro Cafe is a top choice in Forest Hills. The casual yet vibrant atmosphere makes it perfect for any occasion, whether you're out for a quick bite with friends or celebrating a special moment with family. The restaurant's design reflects the warmth and charm of Mexican culture, creating a perfect balance between a cozy dining experience and the lively energy of the community.
The menu at 5 Burro Cafe is as diverse as it is mouthwatering, offering everything from sizzling fajitas to savory tacos, all made with fresh, high-quality ingredients. One of the standout features is the use of local ingredients that create dishes packed with authentic flavors. No wonder the cafe is often praised for its delicious, satisfying meals that keep patrons coming back time and time again.
What Makes the Menu Special at 5 Burro Cafe?
The menu at 5 Burro Cafe is designed to cater to a wide variety of tastes and preferences, which is why it stands out in Forest Hills. From hearty burritos to tangy margaritas, there’s something for everyone. A favorite among many is the grilled chicken fajitas, a perfect balance of smoky flavor and freshness. Pair it with their homemade guacamole, and you’ve got a meal that’s hard to beat.
For those seeking lighter options, the menu also features crisp salads and delicious seafood dishes. Many visitors are also drawn to their specialty cocktails, especially the margaritas, which are perfect for a night out or a relaxing meal. The extensive drink list complements the rich flavors of the food, making it an ideal destination for both food lovers and cocktail enthusiasts.
The location of 5 Burro Cafe adds to the charm, with outdoor seating available for sunny days and a comfortable indoor setting for colder months. Whether you're visiting during the bustling lunchtime rush or enjoying a more peaceful evening, there's always a perfect spot for you to sit and savor the food.
Local Favorites and Customer Reviews: Why 5 Burro Cafe is a Hit
When it comes to customer feedback, 5 Burro Cafe consistently receives rave reviews from patrons, particularly for its attentive service and flavorful dishes. People appreciate the friendly staff who go above and beyond to ensure a great dining experience, making the cafe not just a place to eat, but a destination to enjoy.
Many locals rave about their signature dishes, such as the enchiladas and quesadillas, highlighting the balance of bold, fresh flavors that define the restaurant's culinary offerings. The authentic taste of each dish is evident, with patrons often commenting on how the flavors remind them of traditional Mexican cooking.
Moreover, the cafe’s reputation extends beyond just good food. The ambiance, the service, and the overall experience all contribute to the positive feedback it continues to receive. Whether it's a casual dinner with friends or a family gathering, 5 Burro Cafe stands as one of the top-rated dining spots in Forest Hills.
A Great Choice for Every Occasion
Whether you're in Forest Hills for a visit or you've lived in the neighborhood for years, 5 Burro Cafe is an excellent choice for any occasion. The convenient location makes it easy to swing by for a quick lunch or enjoy a long dinner with friends. The cozy ambiance combined with its delicious menu has earned 5 Burro Cafe a spot on many locals' lists of favorite dining spots in Forest Hills.
From the moment you step into the cafe, the warm atmosphere, welcoming staff, and vibrant decor make it clear why this place is loved by many. Whether you're a regular or a first-time visitor, you’re sure to have a memorable experience. So, the next time you find yourself in Forest Hills, NY, don’t forget to check out 5 Burro Cafe – a true gem that serves up both flavor and fun.
Still my favorite restaurant in existence! The frozen margaritas are TO DIE FOR & they have the best chipotle quesadillas in the world! The cute & cozy ambiance of this place is adorable & the service is always unmatched - 5 out of 5 stars EVERY SINGLE TIME!